Singapore Maths
For many parents in Singapore, Maths has been a challenge these past years because the syllabus has changed much, and the methods of solving have evolved too. More critically, the standards have been raised. Ask any Primary 6 student doing the national Primary School Leaving Exam, and you'll know.
It's no wonder that the US apparently regards Singapore Maths as a benchmark of sort. So, you can have American Math for a subject, and be further challenged by Singapore Maths. That is according to Hub's American boss who has an eight-year-old girl. My Hawaiian friend came to S'pore last year and bought all the assessment books on Maths in the infamous Popular Bookshop, well-known for selling assessment and guide books.
Well, Mother Superior has been drowned in Maths and Grammar last week and this, to guide her precious two for the exams, which incidentally, ends tomorrow - yay! So far, she is familiar with a particular Andrew Er:
...and a particular Dr Fong Ho Kheong, who's the author of most Singapore Maths books. He's so complicated that he published a guide for parents. How thoughtful. I bought two books last year, accidentally.
Dr Fong prides on his number bond method that enables kids to calculate mentally by 'rounding up' to the nearest tens or hundreds. Quite good, except that the questions can be tricky, and when parents are just so used to calculating vertically and not horizontally.
That brings me to Andrew Er, whom I hope, my kids will never have to be taught by him. Consider this question in his P2 book for eight-year-olds, which MS has modified a little due to lack of memory:
Question 1
Mother Superior bought 40 sweets to be shared with her two kids. Faith has 10 more than Grace. How many sweets does Grace have? How many sweets does Faith have?
Now, it looks simple on the surface, but for little girls, that can be pretty heavy, considering I first solved it using Algebra. I, who never did well in Maths, of course. Here's a simpler one that was on Grace's paper for P1, seven-year-olds:
Question 2
Tim shares 36 sweets equally with 5 of his friends. How many does each person get?
Much simpler, but fairly tricky for kids. So many of Grace's friends kept knocking their heads wondering how 36 can be divided by 5.
At 10am now, as I write, they would have finished their paper. Let's really hope they can manage.
But for now, what would your answers be for Questions 1 and 2? ,-)



30 Comments:
At 10:28 AM,
Mickell said…
Faith has 25 sweets while Grace has 15 sweets. I could only solve it using algebra too :p
At 10:29 AM,
Mickell said…
Tim gets 1 sweet while each of his 5 friends gets 7 sweets :)
At 10:31 AM,
Mickell said…
Before i received Christ, my maths was C6. After i received Christ, it became A2 :)
At 10:43 AM,
De Book Worm said…
I've never been good at maths. Makes me wonder how I survived 20 years in the banking industry!!! Unfortunately, my 11 year old seems to be taking after me and when we both have to go through her Maths homework together, I just want to cry. :(
At 10:53 AM,
may said…
I think they have these sort of questions for IQ tests too. one of the reasons I was thankful going into Arts instead of Science is that I didn't have to do add maths! I would've failed miserably and died... sigh...
At 12:31 PM,
fantasyflier said…
its 6 each for tim and friends? I had to use a Cray Supercomp to solve.....
At 3:05 PM,
Lil' Joy said…
1. 15 & 25
2. 6 each
Boy! And I thought I had it tough when I was studying there.
At 5:04 PM,
Leonard said…
maths is certainly a subject that need lots of practice, once practice alot, simple just plug and play, all are the same don't they?
the problem with pri school maths is that we solve it with secondary school methods and not relevant to explain to the kids! Yawnz!
At 12:48 AM,
Simple American said…
Tim's friends get 1 each and Tim gets 31. Tim is a capitalist, forget that equality stuff. hyuk hyuk! ;)
I wonder if my son could do these. There mom does math with them so I don't know.
At 7:32 AM,
Mother Superior said…
SA: Therein lies the main issue: can Maths be interpreted in different ways. The word 'equally' in Qn 2 means different things to a socialist.
Leonard: You're right. Adult methods differ from kids', of course. In Qn 1, the kids were required to use models method. Familiar? OK, go buy Dr Fong's book.
LJ: Bingo! You've got it right, of course. Try that on K when she's ready.
FF: What's Cray Supercomp? Surely a numbers guy like you would have no probs, till you have your own kid, of course.
May: I don't pass IQ tests very well too. Sama, sama...
DBR: Is your 11-yr-old a girl or boy? I think it's a genetic make-up thing - boys tend to have better Maths acumen, though it seems, not always so in primary years.
Mickell: Tim is so sweet to settle with 1 sweet. So long as that equality to him.
At 1:44 PM,
may said…
Happy Mid-Autumn Festival, Mama S!! to your dear girls and hubby too.
At 4:25 PM,
blurblur said…
Maths made me mad...i'm never good at figures and all...i hope Damien doesn't end up like me..;)
At 5:35 PM,
Weiwei said…
My method:
Qn1:
Since Faith has 10 more sweets, therefore, 30 sweets are divided between the 2 of them.
Faith has (10+(40-10)/2)=25 sweets
Grace has ((40-10)/2)= 15 sweets.
Qn2:
Tim + 5 friends = 6people.
Therefore everyone gets 36/6=4 sweets. This question is an IQ question not maths, so it's not fair.
At 10:10 AM,
L B said…
It's hard to count with only two hands.. and headless!
At 5:03 PM,
Robin said…
25-15, and each get 6 in the second case.
yes, not easy..
as usual in Sg, child gets exam, mum gets stress
At 12:50 PM,
See Fei said…
would not bother meself with such difficult thing. will leave it to my sec LOL
seriously, it is no joke to live in a modern world like us. but got to keep up as things are so competitive.
At 8:09 PM,
carcar said…
interesting maths post... erm, anyone need mandarin tuition ? haaa....
im lousy with maths too, but ended up in a job scope need to do calculation very frequent, aih..
At 11:05 PM,
King's wife said…
Tricky for 7 and 8 yr olds.
At 11:33 AM,
Cocka Doodle said…
Faith may have more sweets than Grace. But at the end of the day, Grace has more teeth left! Hahahaha!!!
At 1:00 AM,
manic depressive said…
haiz my son is only in pri one and sometimes i can't answer his problem maths questions also. always tell him to ask his teachers at the day care centre LOL
At 12:41 PM,
fantasyflier said…
Cray Super-computer they had to use one to beat that chess fella Kasparov or something...LOL
At 10:56 PM,
Hiao Auntie said…
okie i'm familiar with pr school maths and for the first one, u need to use model drawing to solve... for the second one, you have to read the question properly, i.e. Tim and his 5 friends = 6 hee.... psle questions always have a few super duper questions that most children find hard to answer... nonetheless, i think the trick is in practising and practising... just like when we were doing ten year series to prepare for our O level...
At 2:58 PM,
DCYQ said…
This post has been removed by the author.
At 3:00 PM,
DCYQ said…
This post has been removed by the author.
At 3:04 PM,
DCYQ said…
Hi all. I'm a student of singapore. I'm in secondary school now(aka high school).
solution:
1.
_________
G |_________|___
F |_________|___|
total: 40
Grace: (40-10)/2=15
Faith: 15+10=25
Grace has 15 sweets while faith has 25 sweets
2.
36/6=5(Tim and his 5 friends. This is because the word "with" is used.)
the answer is 5.
Ps. the line for the modal is a bit weird. Please don't bother about it.
At 4:19 PM,
applepie said…
sorry i am P3 this year.
i thought 36/6 should be 6 right?
At 8:38 PM,
Anonymous said…
ah!!!my maths is very weak i think maybe this could help me....ok maths is fun but.....so so irritating...must really brainstorm
At 8:40 PM,
Anonymous said…
ahhhhh!!
i am very weak at maths i think this could help me....maths is complecated but if we know,its fun..
At 11:29 AM,
Anonymous said…
thiese questions are too easy.i did them during primary one exam.
At 8:21 PM,
mr fong said…
All answers are above, haha... Yes they are quite hard for p1p2 :D
Post a Comment
<< Home